Variety

There’s a reason we call this The Variety. This collection brings together a wide range of our cheeses in one beautiful wooden crate. We’ve selected the crowd-pleasing staples that represent the heart of our creamery — from our world-class, marbled Colby to our buttery-smooth Jacks. It’s the ultimate "starter kit" for anyone who wants to experience the authentic, award-winning taste of Muscoda.

What's Inside (6/8oz. each):
•Colby (2026 World Cheese Championship – Best in Class): A mild, creamy Wisconsin classic with its signature "laciness" and mellow flavor.
•Colby Jack: The iconic Wisconsin blend of mild Colby and velvety Monterey Jack.
•Dill Havarti (2024 World Cheese Championship – Best in Class): Our ultra-creamy Havarti with a bright, herbal finish.
•Pepper Jack: Smooth Monterey Jack with just the right amount of jalapeño kick.
•Garlic Pesto Jack: A vibrant, herb-forward Jack infused with aromatic basil and savory garlic.
•Mild Cheddar: A smooth, gentle classic that’s a favorite for all ages.
•Monterey Jack (2026 World Cheese Championship – Third Place): Our versatile, buttery-smooth signature cheese.
•Bruschetta Jack: Infused with garlic, basil, and sun-dried tomatoes.
•Wild Morel & Leek Jack: A savory, "forest-to-table" favorite featuring earthy morel mushrooms and sweet garden leeks.
•Banana Pepper Jack: Our smooth, creamy Monterey Jack infused with tangy, mild banana peppers for a bright, zesty bite that’s full of flavor without the heavy heat.
•Muscoda Mayhem Colby Jack: A bold favorite that packs a punch, blending our classic marbled cheese with a lively kick of heat.
•One of our signature savory cheese spreads, featuring a delicious rotation of one of four artisan flavors.
•12oz Beef Summer Sausage
•5oz East Shore Mustard
•2oz East Shore Pretzel

Because our cheese is perishable, we ship all products via Second Day Air AND we ship in insulated containers with ice packs. View Our Shipping Policy