Crowd Pleaser

Celebrate the very best of Wisconsin cheesemaking with the Crowd pleaser. This curated selection features a lineup of our most decorated and beloved cheeses, showcasing the craftsmanship that has earned us top honors at the World Championship Cheese Contest. From the smooth, marbled perfection of our "Best in Class" Colby to the zesty kick of our signature Jack varieties, this box is a true tribute to the flavors that put Muscoda on the map.

What's Inside (6/8oz. each):
•Bruschetta Jack: Infused with garlic, basil, and sun-dried tomatoes.
•Colby (2026 World Cheese Championship – Best in Class): A mild, creamy Wisconsin classic with its signature "laciness" and mellow flavor.
•Colby Jack: The iconic Wisconsin blend of mild Colby and velvety Monterey Jack.
•Garlic Pesto Jack: A vibrant, herb-forward Jack infused with aromatic basil and savory garlic.
•Mild Cheddar: A traditional, perfectly aged favorite.
•Horseradish Cheddar: A sharp, aged cheddar blended with zesty horseradish for a bold, pungent punch that delivers a sharp and savory kick.
•Muscoda Mayhem Colby Jack: A bold favorite that packs a punch, blending our classic marbled cheese with a lively kick of heat.
•Wild Morel & Leek Jack: A savory, "forest-to-table" favorite featuring earthy morel mushrooms and sweet garden leeks.
•Banana Pepper Jack: Our smooth, creamy Monterey Jack infused with tangy, mild banana peppers for a bright, zesty bite that’s full of flavor without the heavy heat.
•Spicy Dill Pickle Jack: Our newest cheese is a  twist on classic Monterey Jack featuring mouthwatering dill pickle flavor and a kick of ghost chili flakes for an approachable, crowd-pleasing heat.

Because our cheese is perishable, we ship all products via Second Day Air AND we ship in insulated containers with ice packs. View Our Shipping Policy